Reasons Why Tough Love Doesn't Work?

May 2, 2023

When maladaptive behavior or risky actions threaten our loved ones, tough love may be the only way to help them learn.

While this approach is often useful, it can also be harmful to those we love. In some cases, it even encourages them to continue their unhealthy coping strategies or drug use.

1. It’s the Right Thing to Do

When we’re struggling with relationships, it can feel like the best way to solve our problems is through a harsh approach, like tough love. But the truth is that this approach often doesn’t work.

It can even harm relationships. Whether it’s in your marriage, a workplace or between partners, it can create long-lasting pain for both sides of the equation.

The right thing to do is to establish boundaries and hold people accountable for their behavior. This may not be easy, but it’s necessary to protect your own well-being while also respecting the other person.

Many families, especially those with a loved one suffering from addiction, believe that tough love is the only way to get their children to stop using drugs or alcohol. However, there are no reliable studies that prove that this approach works.

2. It’s the Right Thing to Say

Tough love is an often-used term to describe a method for dealing with a loved one who’s struggling with behavior problems, addiction, and emotional issues. It typically involves a concerned loved one gathering a team to meet and formulate a loving plan that will hopefully result in change.

The process of executing tough love isn’t always easy. It requires commitment, dedication, and a clear set of objectives and obstacles to overcome.

When used wisely, tough love can spark accountability and self-sufficiency in your loved one. It’s also about safeguarding your own well-being while considering your loved one’s needs, boundaries, and responsibilities.

It’s about empowering your loved one to make healthy choices and live a more fulfilling life. It’s about recognizing and addressing truly harmful behaviors like infidelity, sexual compromise, substance abuse, and addiction.

3. It’s the Right Thing to Do for Yourself

Tough love can be a great way to encourage accountability and self-sufficiency. It can also be used to address problematic behavior in a relationship.

However, if tough love is used incorrectly or in the wrong context, it can become abusive and lead to negative outcomes. It can also create a lot of shame and guilt in the person being targeted, which can have an unintended effect on their mental health.

When someone is displaying truly harmful behavior, such as infidelity, pornography, addictions, and substance abuse, the best course of action may be to use tough love to try to change them.

But if you’re using tough love to encourage a friend or loved one to make changes, you should be careful not to be needlessly hurtful. Ultimately, your friend or loved one needs to listen to your words and take them to heart if they want to see the change happen.

4. It’s the Right Thing to Do for Your Partner

Tough love is the right thing to do for your partner if they are in danger of harming themselves, others or their relationship. It can be the last resort to get them to see that their behavior is destructive.

Getting them to change is not always easy, and the person may not be able to forgive you or thank you for your help until they have made a significant progress in their life.

When tough love is used effectively, it can help your partner learn to set boundaries and take responsibility for their actions. It can also show them that you have their best interests at heart, and that you are willing to go above and beyond for them.

However, it is important to remember that using tough love too often or in an extreme manner can be demeaning and humiliating for your partner. It can also create feelings of shame and guilt in them, which are unhealthy for them and your relationship.


We believe that a healthy mind and body are essential to a happy life. We bring you the latest meditations and advice on health, mind, body, & soul.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram